Guide · Money and calculators
The 4% rule: where it comes from and what it assumes
Updated
The 4% rule says a retiree can withdraw 4% of a portfolio in the first year, then the same amount raised each year for inflation. In Bengen's 1994 study of US returns since 1926, a half-stock, half-bond portfolio never ran out in under 33 years; the 1998 Trinity study found high success rates. It describes the past, not a guarantee.
Key takeaways
- The 4% applies to the first year only; after that the dollar amount rises with inflation, whatever markets do.
- Bengen's 1994 study tested US common stocks and intermediate-term Treasuries, and favored mixes with 50% to 75% in stocks.
- The Trinity study reported success rates: with inflation-adjusted withdrawals, 4% lasted 30 years in 95% to 98% of past periods for mixes with 50% to 100% in stocks.
- The order of returns early in retirement matters as much as their average.
- Both studies used US history only and a fixed spending rule; the result is a rule of thumb, not a promise.
On this page
What the 4% rule says
The 4% rule is a guideline for spending from savings in retirement. In the first year, withdraw 4% of the portfolio's value. In every later year, withdraw the same dollar amount adjusted for inflation, regardless of how the portfolio has done. In US market history, a balanced portfolio of stocks and bonds spent this way lasted at least 30 years.
The 4% figure is used only once, to set the first year's amount. With a $1,000,000 portfolio, the first withdrawal is $40,000. If inflation runs at 3%, the second year's withdrawal is $41,200 and the third $42,436, even if the portfolio has fallen in the meantime. By year 30, at a steady 3%, it is about $94,263.
Turned around, the rule implies a target: savings of 25 times the first year's spending from the portfolio, because 4% is one twenty-fifth.
Where it comes from
Bengen, 1994. Financial planner William Bengen's article "Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data", in the October 1994 Journal of Financial Planning, tested withdrawal rates against US market history from 1926. Using Ibbotson Associates' data, he modeled portfolios of common stocks and intermediate-term Treasuries, continually rebalanced, with a first-year withdrawal set as a percentage of the portfolio and raised with inflation thereafter. Starting in each historical year, he asked how long the money lasted. For a 50% stock, 50% bond portfolio, a first-year rate of 4% had in no past case run out in fewer than 33 years, while 4.25% could run out in as little as 28. He compared mixes from 0% to 100% stocks and concluded that 50% to 75% in stocks was the best starting allocation.
The Trinity study, 1998. Philip Cooley, Carl Hubbard and Daniel Walz, finance professors at Trinity University, published "Retirement Savings: Choosing a Withdrawal Rate That Is Sustainable" in the February 1998 AAII Journal. Using returns from 1926 to 1995, they tested withdrawal rates from 3% to 12%, payout periods of 15, 20, 25 and 30 years, and five mixes from all stocks to all bonds, with the S&P 500 for stocks and long-term, high-grade corporate bonds for bonds. For each combination they reported a success rate: the percentage of past payout periods in which the portfolio lasted to the end. With withdrawals raised each year for inflation, 4% over 30 years succeeded in 95% of the 41 overlapping periods with all stocks, 98% with 75% stocks, 95% with 50% stocks, 71% with 25% stocks and 20% with all bonds.
What "4%" assumed
The figure carries the assumptions of the studies that produced it:
- A 30-year retirement. Longer periods need lower rates.
- Fixed, inflation-adjusted spending. No cutting back after a bad year, no extra spending after a good one.
- A specific portfolio. US common stocks (the S&P 500 in the Trinity study) and either intermediate-term Treasuries (Bengen) or long-term, high-grade corporate bonds (Trinity), in fixed proportions.
- US history. Both studies used one country's record. A rule calibrated on it carries that market's outcomes.
- "Success" means not running out. A portfolio that ends with $1 counts the same as one that doubles.
- Costs and taxes. The Trinity study did not adjust for taxes or transaction costs, and Bengen assumed tax-deferred accounts. Fees and taxes reduce what the portfolio can support, so a withdrawal rate tested on returns before those costs overstates what is left to spend after them.
Sequence of returns: why order matters
Two hypothetical retirees each start with $1,000,000 and withdraw $40,000 at the start of every year. Both earn the same five annual returns, in opposite order:
| Year | Retiree A return | A's balance | Retiree B return | B's balance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | −20% | $768,000 | +10% | $1,056,000 |
| 2 | −10% | $655,200 | +25% | $1,270,000 |
| 3 | +15% | $707,480 | +15% | $1,414,500 |
| 4 | +25% | $834,350 | −10% | $1,237,050 |
| 5 | +10% | $873,785 | −20% | $957,640 |
The returns multiply to the same total, and without withdrawals both would end equal. With withdrawals, A ends about $84,000 behind B, because A sold more of the portfolio while prices were low. This is sequence risk, and it is why the rule's worst historical cases are retirements that began just before a long stretch of poor returns: in Bengen's data the shortest-lived portfolios were those caught by the 1973–1974 decline and its high inflation.
Criticism and limits
The rule is easy to misuse:
- It is not a forecast. It reports what would have worked in the past. Future returns on stocks and bonds may be lower or higher than in the historical record.
- It ignores flexibility. The Trinity authors expected mid-course corrections to be likely, and Bengen showed that trimming withdrawals after a bad start left a retiree better off. A rule that never adjusts can be too cautious in good markets and too rigid in bad ones.
- It ignores other income. Pensions, Social Security and part-time work change how much a portfolio has to supply.
- It ignores length of life. Someone retiring at 45 faces a far longer horizon than the 30 years the rule was tested for.
Use it as a starting point
Funkfolio's FIRE calculator shows the 4% rule as one input rather than assuming it, alongside years to financial independence at a given savings rate. The compound interest calculator covers the saving years, and the inflation calculator shows how a fixed sum loses purchasing power. The model portfolios show stock and bond mixes with their real returns, worst years and deepest drawdowns, the raw material of any withdrawal study. To see why an average return overstates what a portfolio delivers, read CAGR vs average return.
Questions and answers
What is the 4% rule?
It is a rule of thumb for retirement spending: withdraw 4% of your portfolio in the first year of retirement, then increase that dollar amount each year by the rate of inflation. In US market history since 1926, as studied by William Bengen in 1994, that spending lasted at least 30 years for a balanced stock and bond portfolio.
How much do I need to retire using the 4% rule?
The rule implies savings of 25 times your first year's spending from the portfolio, since 4% is one twenty-fifth. To spend $40,000 a year from savings, that is $1,000,000. This says nothing about taxes, fees, other income or how long you will live, which change the answer.
Who created the 4% rule?
Financial planner William Bengen, in an article in the Journal of Financial Planning in October 1994. In 1998 Philip Cooley, Carl Hubbard and Daniel Walz, professors at Trinity University, published a related study in the AAII Journal that became known as the Trinity study.
Is the 4% rule still valid?
It is a description of past US results, not a guarantee. It assumes a 30-year retirement, a fixed inflation-adjusted withdrawal, a particular mix of stocks and bonds and US market history. A longer retirement, higher fees, a different portfolio or future returns unlike the past can all make 4% too high or too low.
Sources
- Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data (William P. Bengen, Journal of Financial Planning, October 1994; the Journal's March 2004 reprint) — Financial Planning Association. Accessed .
- Retirement Savings: Choosing a Withdrawal Rate That Is Sustainable (Cooley, Hubbard and Walz, AAII Journal, February 1998) — American Association of Individual Investors. Accessed .
Live data and tools
Cite this page
Funkfolio, “The 4% rule: where it comes from and what it assumes”, data as of 12 November 2026. https://funkfolio.com/learn/money/four-percent-rule
General information, not investment advice.