Guide · Money and calculators

CAGR vs average return: why the two numbers differ

Updated

CAGR, the compound annual growth rate, is the constant yearly rate that turns a starting value into an ending value: (end ÷ start)^(1 ÷ years) − 1. The average (arithmetic) return is the plain mean of the yearly returns. When returns vary, CAGR is lower than the average, because losses shrink the base that later gains apply to.

Key takeaways

  • CAGR = (ending value ÷ starting value)^(1 ÷ years) − 1.
  • A gain of 50% followed by a loss of 50% averages 0% but leaves you with 75% of what you started with: a CAGR of −13.4%.
  • The more returns swing, the further CAGR falls below the average return.
  • Fund performance tables quote average annual total return as a compounded rate, the same idea as CAGR.
  • CAGR hides the path: two investments with the same CAGR can have had very different drops along the way.
On this page

CAGR and average return in one line each

The compound annual growth rate (CAGR) is the single constant yearly rate that would turn a starting value into an ending value over a number of years. The average return, or arithmetic mean, is the yearly returns added up and divided by the number of years. The first describes what happened to the money; the second describes a typical year. When returns vary from year to year, CAGR is always lower.

The formulas

  • CAGR = (ending value ÷ starting value)^(1 ÷ years) − 1
  • Average return = (r1 + r2 + … + rn) ÷ n

CAGR uses only the two end points and the time between them. The average uses every yearly return but ignores that each one applies to a different starting amount.

A worked example: the two numbers diverge

Hypothetical: $10,000 rises 50% in year one, to $15,000, and falls 50% in year two, to $7,500.

  • Average return: (50% − 50%) ÷ 2 = 0%
  • CAGR: (7,500 ÷ 10,000)^(1/2) − 1 = −13.4% a year

The average says you broke even. Your account says you lost a quarter of the money. CAGR agrees with your account: $10,000 × 0.866 × 0.866 = $7,500.

A milder, three-year example:

Year Return Value at year end
Start $10,000
1 +10% $11,000
2 +20% $13,200
3 −15% $11,220
  • Average return: (10 + 20 − 15) ÷ 3 = 5.0% a year
  • CAGR: (11,220 ÷ 10,000)^(1/3) − 1 = 3.9% a year

Check: $10,000 × 1.039^3 ≈ $11,216, and the small difference is rounding. $10,000 × 1.05^3 would be $11,576, which never happened.

Why volatility separates them

A 50% loss needs a 100% gain to recover; a 20% loss needs 25%. Losses take a bigger bite out of compounding than the same-sized gains add back, so the more returns swing, the further CAGR falls below the average.

A common approximation captures the size of the gap: CAGR ≈ average return − (variance of returns ÷ 2), where variance is the square of the standard deviation. In the three-year example, the returns deviate from their 5% mean by +5, +15 and −20 points, giving a variance of about 0.0217. Half of that is about 1.1 points, and 5.0% − 1.1% ≈ 3.9%, the actual CAGR. Two portfolios with the same average return but different volatility end with different amounts of money; the steadier one ends with more.

Where you meet each number

US mutual funds report "average annual total return" for 1, 5 and 10 years. The SEC's formula for it is P(1 + T)^n = ERV: the rate T that, compounded over n years, turns a hypothetical $1,000 payment P into its ending redeemable value ERV, with distributions reinvested and the maximum sales load deducted. That is a CAGR after the fund's charges. Rule 482 requires fund advertisements that quote average annual total return to compute it by the same methods.

Arithmetic averages turn up in summaries of historical market returns and in forecasts of a single year. Applying one to multi-year growth overstates it, and the more volatile the asset, the larger the overstatement.

How CAGR misleads

  • It hides the path. A stock that rose steadily 8% a year and one that fell 50% before tripling can show the same CAGR. CAGR says nothing about drawdowns along the way.
  • It depends on the end points. Starting at a market peak or ending just after a crash moves CAGR a lot. Check several periods.
  • Price growth is not total return. A CAGR of share prices leaves out dividends; a total-return CAGR includes them reinvested.
  • It needs positive end points. CAGR cannot be computed when the start or end value is zero or negative, such as a company's earnings turning from a loss to a profit.

CAGR on Funkfolio

Each company's measure pages, such as Apple's revenue, state the compound growth per year over the latest five and ten fiscal years, and give no rate when either end value is zero or negative. The CAGR calculator works out the rate from a start value, an end value and a number of years, or the reverse, and the stock return calculator does it for a real stock's price history. The model portfolios set each portfolio's return beside its worst year and deepest drawdown, the path that a CAGR on its own hides. See also compound interest and dollar-cost averaging.

Questions and answers

How do you calculate CAGR?

Divide the ending value by the starting value, raise the result to the power of one divided by the number of years, and subtract 1. An investment that grows from $10,000 to $11,220 over three years has a CAGR of (11,220 ÷ 10,000)^(1/3) − 1, about 3.9% a year.

Why is CAGR lower than the average return?

Because returns compound. A loss reduces the amount that the next year's gain applies to, so equal percentage gains and losses do not cancel out. The average return ignores that; CAGR does not. The gap grows with the size of the swings, and the two are equal only when every year's return is the same.

Which is better to use, CAGR or average return?

For what an investment actually did to your money over a period, CAGR, because it is the rate that reproduces the real ending value. The arithmetic average describes a typical single year and is used in some statistical work, but applying it to multi-year growth overstates the result.

Is average annual return on a fund the same as CAGR?

In US fund documents, yes in substance. The SEC's formula for average annual total return, P(1 + T)^n = ERV, finds the compounded yearly rate T that turns a hypothetical $1,000 into its ending value over 1, 5 or 10 years, which is a CAGR including reinvested distributions.

Sources

  1. Disclosure of Mutual Fund After-Tax Returns, Final Rule (Release No. 33-7941), with the Form N-1A average annual total return formula — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Accessed .
  2. Amendments to Investment Company Advertising Rules (Release No. 33-8294) — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Accessed .

Cite this page

Funkfolio, “CAGR vs average return: why the two numbers differ”, data as of 12 November 2026. https://funkfolio.com/learn/money/cagr

General information, not investment advice.