Guide · Superinvestors and 13F filings
Does copying superinvestors work? What the research says
Updated
The evidence is mixed and narrow. Studies the SEC reviewed in 2020 found that some simulated copycat funds matched the funds they copied, and that managers hide some of their best-performing positions through confidential treatment. None shows that copying a famous investor's 13F reliably beats the market after delay, costs and the selection of whom to copy.
Key takeaways
- Research cited by the SEC found that some simulated copycat portfolios matched the performance of the funds they copied; it did not find a dependable edge over the market.
- Managers have used confidential treatment to delay disclosing positions that went on to earn higher returns than their other holdings.
- One study found hedge funds' own performance fell after they began filing 13Fs, consistent with others free-riding on their ideas.
- A copier trades only after the filing appears, up to 45 days or more after the quarter-end snapshot, sees no shorts or hedges, and pays its own trading costs and taxes.
- Choosing whom to copy after a strong record is a form of survivorship bias that no back-test of famous names escapes.
On this page
Does copying superinvestors work?
The honest answer is that the research does not establish it. When the SEC reviewed the academic literature on 13F disclosure in 2020, in a proposal to raise the filing threshold, it found "partial evidence": studies in which simulated copycat funds matched the funds they copied, studies showing managers hide some of their best ideas, and one showing that disclosure hurt the managers who were copied. None of that adds up to a finding that copying a famous investor's filing reliably beats the market.
This guide sets out what those studies found, as the SEC described them, and the practical obstacles any copier faces.
What the research found
The SEC's 2020 proposing release (Release No. 34-89290) discussed the research in its economic analysis, because copying is a cost of disclosure to the managers being copied. Its summary, in order:
Copycat portfolios. "Many studies test for copycatting profits by simulating funds that copy reported 13F portfolios, and the studies generally find that some copycat funds can match the performance of the copied funds." The SEC cited Frank, Poterba, Shackelford and Shoven, "Copycat Funds" (Journal of Law and Economics, 2004), which studies copycat funds that buy the same assets as actively managed mutual funds as soon as those holdings are disclosed, and Verbeek and Wang, "Better than the Original? The Relative Success of Copycat Funds" (Journal of Banking and Finance, 2013). The working-paper abstract of the first states its sample: "a limited sample of high expense funds in the 1990s". It found the copied funds' returns significantly higher before expenses, and the copycats' returns "statistically indistinguishable, and possibly higher" after expenses. That is mutual funds' semiannual disclosures, not hedge funds' 13Fs. Note the comparison: matching the copied fund, not beating the market. No abstract of the Verbeek and Wang paper could be read for this guide, so only the SEC's summary stands for it. The SEC added that these studies do not test whether the copying harms the copied managers or their clients.
Hidden positions. "Several studies show that managers use confidential treatment requests to delay reporting stocks on Form 13F that have higher future returns than their other stocks." The SEC cited Aragon, Hertzel and Shi, "Why Do Hedge Funds Avoid Disclosure? Evidence from Confidential 13F Filings" (Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 2013), and Agarwal, Jiang, Tang and Yang, "Uncovering Hedge Fund Skill from the Portfolio Holdings They Hide" (Journal of Finance, 2013). Their abstracts say more. Aragon, Hertzel and Shi found that confidential positions "earn positive and significant abnormal returns over the post-filing confidential period", and that managers seek confidentiality more often for illiquid positions more susceptible to front-running. Agarwal and co-authors found that confidential holdings "exhibit superior performance up to 12 months". Neither abstract states a sample period. For a copier this cuts the wrong way: some of the positions most worth seeing are the ones held back.
Filing late in the window. A working paper by Christoffersen, Danesh and Musto found that managers more likely to face front-running choose to file at the end of the 45-day window. An earlier version's abstract says it looked at 14 years of 13F filings and found that front-running and voting, "but not copycatting", motivate the delays.
The cost to the copied. One study, Shi, "The Impact of Portfolio Disclosure on Hedge Fund Performance" (Journal of Financial Economics, 2017), examined hedge funds around the time they began filing 13Fs and reported reduced performance after disclosure, possibly "due to the revelation of trade secrets and free-riding activities". The effect was concentrated among funds holding more illiquid stocks, with lower turnover and more concentrated portfolios, among other traits. Its abstract could not be read for this guide; this paragraph is the SEC's summary.
Where no sample period is given above, neither the SEC's summary nor the abstract states one, and the findings belong to the funds, periods and methods those authors chose. They are evidence about the past, not a forecast.
The caveats every copier faces
Delay. A 13F is due 45 days after the quarter ends and values holdings at the quarter's close. A copier buys after the filing appears, at a later price, and never sees positions opened and closed within the quarter. See 13F deadlines.
Incompleteness. The SEC's FAQ says short positions and options the manager wrote are not reported. Cash, most bonds and foreign-only listings are not on the form either. A long position that the manager hedged with a short you cannot see is not the same bet once copied without the hedge. See how to read a 13F portfolio.
Survivorship. The investors people choose to copy are the ones whose records already look good. A back-test that starts with today's famous names has picked the winners using information nobody had at the start of the test. Managers who were famous in an earlier decade and then lagged are rarely on the list.
Costs and taxes. A simulated copycat fund in a study may assume costs a real person does not face, or ignore some they do: commissions, bid-ask spreads, taxes on gains when the copied manager sells.
Fit. A manager's portfolio is built for its own clients, time horizon and risk limits. A 15% position in a fund with a large short book and a long horizon is a different thing in a personal account.
A worked example of the delay
A hypothetical manager buys a stock at $40 in early July. It closes the quarter on September 30 at $46, and the 13F, filed on November 14, shows the new position. A copier buys on November 15 at $52. The manager's gain on paper is 30%; the copier starts 13% above the price on the filing and 30% above where the manager bought. If the stock then falls back to $46, the manager is still up 15% and the copier is down about 11.5%. Same stock, same decision, different outcome, purely from timing.
How to use Funkfolio's superinvestor data with that in mind
Funkfolio shows each tracked investor's latest reported holdings, the date of the filing and the changes since the previous one, with no ranking of who to follow. The superinvestors hub lists everyone tracked, buys shows which stocks several investors bought in their latest quarter, and most-owned shows which stocks they hold in common. Each investor page, such as Warren Buffett's, sets the reported price beside the current one, so the delay is visible. These are records of what managers reported, not recommendations; the about page explains how they are built.
Questions and answers
Can you beat the market by copying a superinvestor's 13F?
The research summarized by the SEC does not show that. It found that some copycat strategies could match the funds they copied, which is not the same as beating the market, and the studies did not test every manager, period or cost. Past results of any copying strategy do not predict future results.
Why would copying a 13F work at all?
If a manager has real skill, part of it may still show in the holdings a few weeks later, especially for long-term holders who trade rarely. Copying captures only what is still in the portfolio when the filing becomes public, at the prices of that later date.
What is the biggest problem with copying 13F filings?
Delay and incompleteness. A filing can describe holdings 45 days old, so the copier buys later and at different prices. The filing also leaves out short positions, written options, cash and foreign shares, so the copier may hold the long side of a position that the manager had hedged.
Do managers try to stop people copying them?
Some do. The SEC's 2020 review cited studies finding that managers use confidential treatment requests to delay reporting certain stocks, and that managers more exposed to front-running tend to file at the end of the 45-day window.
Sources
- Reporting Threshold for Institutional Investment Managers (proposed rule, Release No. 34-89290), section on economic effects — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Accessed .
- Frequently Asked Questions About Form 13F — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Division of Investment Management. Accessed .
- Copycat Funds: Information Disclosure Regulation and the Returns to Active Management in the Mutual Fund Industry (Frank, Poterba, Shackelford and Shoven, Journal of Law and Economics, vol. 47, no. 2, 2004; working-paper abstract read via Crossref) — The Journal of Law and Economics. Accessed .
- Why Do Hedge Funds Avoid Disclosure? Evidence from Confidential 13F Filings (Aragon, Hertzel and Shi, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, vol. 48, no. 5, 2013; abstract read via Crossref) — Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis. Accessed .
- Uncovering Hedge Fund Skill from the Portfolio Holdings They Hide (Agarwal, Jiang, Tang and Yang, Journal of Finance, vol. 68, no. 2, 2013; abstract read via Crossref) — The Journal of Finance. Accessed .
- Why Do Institutions Delay Reporting Their Shareholdings? Evidence from Form 13F (Christoffersen, Danesh and Musto, SSRN working paper, 2015; abstract read via Crossref) — SSRN. Accessed .
Live data and tools
Cite this page
Funkfolio, “Does copying superinvestors work? What the research says”, data as of 12 November 2026. https://funkfolio.com/learn/superinvestors/does-copying-superinvestors-work
General information, not investment advice.