Guide · Stock research
Short interest vs short volume: what is the difference?
Updated
Short interest is the number of shares sold short and still open on a settlement date, reported twice a month. Daily short sale volume is the number of shares sold short in one day's trades; FINRA's file covers only off-exchange trades. Much of that volume is closed the same day, so it cannot be read as open positions.
Key takeaways
- Short interest is a position on a date; short sale volume is trading during a day. They are never added together.
- FINRA's daily short sale volume file covers trades reported to its off-exchange facilities during regular trading hours.
- Short sales are routine for market makers, many of whose short positions open and close within the day.
- The SEC says daily short volume cannot be combined with short interest to rebuild daily short positions.
- Fails to deliver are an outstanding balance of shares not delivered; the SEC says they are not evidence of naked short selling.
On this page
Two numbers that answer different questions
Short interest answers: how many shares are sold short and still open, as of one settlement date? It is collected by FINRA from its member firms twice a month, as of the middle and end of each month (SEC Release 34-98738). The guide to short interest covers it in detail.
Daily short sale volume answers: how many shares were sold short in one day's trades? It says nothing about whether those positions were still open at the end of the day.
The SEC's 2023 release quotes FINRA's own guidance on the distinction: "The short interest data is just a snapshot that reflects short positions held by brokerage firms at a specific moment in time on two discrete days each month. The Short Sale Volume Daily File reflects the aggregate volume of trades within certain parameters executed as short sales on individual trade dates." The SEC adds that the daily volume data do not distinguish short sales that build economic short positions from those meant for liquidity provision or hedging, and so "may not be combined with the bimonthly short interest data to construct aggregate daily short positions."
What FINRA's daily file counts
FINRA's daily short sale volume file aggregates, for each exchange-listed stock, the short sale trades reported to a FINRA trade reporting facility (TRF) or its alternative display facility (ADF): trades executed away from the exchanges (SEC Release 34-98738). FINRA describes the fields as reported share volume during regular trading hours (FINRA). Each line reads:
Date | Symbol | ShortVolume | ShortExemptVolume | TotalVolume | Market
Three details matter when reading it (FINRA file):
- TotalVolume is off-exchange volume only, the trades reported to those facilities. It is not all trading in the stock, so short volume divided by it is a share of off-exchange trading, not of the market.
- ShortVolume already includes the short-exempt trades. FINRA's description of the short volume field covers "short sale and short sale exempt trades", so the two columns are not added.
- Volumes can include fractions of a share, so they are not whole-share counts.
Why short volume is large on ordinary days
Short selling is part of how market makers work. Market makers stand ready to buy and sell at publicly quoted prices even when no other buyers or sellers are present, so they must sell to a buyer even when the security is in temporary short supply, the SEC explains; those engaged in bona fide market making are excepted from the requirement to locate shares before selling short (SEC).
A 2014 SEC staff study found short selling at nearly 50% of trading volume, up over the previous five years, while short interest had been fairly steady since the end of 2008. It concluded that positions closed within the trading day drive the increase, noting that market makers and high-frequency traders typically open and close short positions within the day. In November 2013, it reported, short interest averaged 8.13 times daily short selling volume (SEC staff study).
A worked example
A hypothetical stock has 50 million shares sold short at the last settlement date. Over one day, 8 million shares trade off-exchange.
- A market maker sells 3 million shares to buyers, short, through the day, and buys 3 million back before the close. Its position at the end of the day is unchanged.
- A fund sells 1 million shares short and keeps the position.
FINRA's file for that day would show short volume of 4 million out of 8 million: 50% of reported off-exchange volume. The next short interest figure would reflect only the fund's 1 million, among every other change up to the settlement date: 51 million if nothing else moved, a rise of 2%.
A short volume share of 50% looks alarming and describes, here, mostly trades that were closed the same day. That is why the two numbers are never added and never substituted for each other.
Fails to deliver
A third data set is often read alongside these two. A fail to deliver occurs when a seller does not deliver securities to the buyer when delivery is due, and it can result from either a short or a long sale; the SEC lists ordinary causes, such as delays in customers delivering shares to a broker or problems with transferring physical certificates (SEC).
The SEC publishes, for each stock and settlement date, the total balance of shares that have failed to be delivered, as recorded in the National Securities Clearing Corporation's Continuous Net Settlement system. The first half of a month is published at the end of that month and the second half around the 15th of the next (SEC). The SEC is explicit about what the figures do not show:
- They are a balance, not a day's new fails: outstanding fails plus new ones, less those settled that day, so "the age of fails cannot be determined by looking at these numbers."
- The sources of the fails on one day need not be the same as the day before or after.
- Fails "are not necessarily the result of short selling, and are not evidence of abusive short selling or 'naked' short selling."
- A stock with no outstanding fails on a date has no record at all for that date.
Reading them together on Funkfolio
A company's short interest page, for example Apple's or Coca-Cola's, shows all three, each named in full and dated: short interest with its settlement date, daily short sale volume with its trade date, and fails to deliver from the SEC's files. FINRA figures carry "Source: FINRA". The three are never summed, and a twice-monthly figure is never presented as today's.
The rankings by short interest and by days to cover use short interest only, never daily short sale volume.
Questions and answers
Is short volume the same as short interest?
No. Short interest is the number of shares sold short and not yet covered on a settlement date, published twice a month. Short sale volume is the number of shares sold short in a single day's trades. A short sale that is bought back before the day ends adds to short volume but never appears in short interest.
Why is short sale volume so large on ordinary days?
Short selling is routine for market makers, who sell to buyers from a short position and buy back later, often within the same day. A 2014 SEC staff study found short selling at nearly 50% of trading volume, while short interest stayed fairly steady, and attributed the rise to positions closed within the day.
What does FINRA's daily short sale volume file cover?
It aggregates, for each stock, the short sale trades reported to FINRA's trade reporting facilities and its alternative display facility during regular trading hours: trades executed off the exchanges. Its total volume column is the off-exchange volume reported there, not all trading in the stock.
What are fails to deliver?
A fail to deliver occurs when shares are not delivered by the settlement date. The SEC publishes the outstanding balance of fails for each stock, twice a month. It notes that fails can arise on both long and short sales and are not evidence of abusive or naked short selling.
Sources
- Short Position and Short Activity Reporting by Institutional Investment Managers (Release No. 34-98738, 2023) — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Accessed .
- Short Sale Position and Transaction Reporting (staff study, June 2014) — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Division of Economic and Risk Analysis. Accessed .
- Reg SHO Daily File: dataset description and fields — FINRA. Accessed .
- Daily short sale volume file, consolidated NMS, trade date November 10, 2026 — FINRA. Accessed .
- Fails-to-Deliver Data — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Accessed .
- Key Points About Regulation SHO — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Accessed .
Live data and tools
Cite this page
Funkfolio, “Short interest vs short volume: what is the difference?”, data as of 12 November 2026. https://funkfolio.com/learn/stocks/short-interest-vs-short-volume
General information, not investment advice.