Franco-Nevada vs Vale
Franco-Nevada (FNV), materials, and Vale (VALE), materials, side by side on market value, valuation, margins, balance sheet and price change. Higher and lower are marked; neither is called better.
Franco-Nevada is worth $47.7B on the stock market and Vale $44.3B: Franco-Nevada is valued at 8% more. Franco-Nevada trades at 30.2 times earnings and Vale at 65.1; operating margins in their latest fiscal years were 74.3% and 15.4%. Over the past year Franco-Nevada's share price has moved +23.0% and Vale's -14.1%.
Key facts
- Franco-Nevada market value
- $47.7B
- Vale market value
- $44.3B
- Franco-Nevada P/E
- 30.2
- Vale P/E
- 65.1
- Franco-Nevada revenue
- $1.8BFY to 2025-12-31
- Vale revenue
- $38.4BFY to 2025-12-31
- Superinvestors holding both
- 0
Market values as of .
| Measure | Franco-Nevada | Vale |
|---|---|---|
| Sector | Materials | Materials |
| Country | ||
| Fiscal year ends | 2025-12-31 | 2025-12-31 |
| Size | ||
| Market cap | $47.7Bhigher | $44.3Blower |
| Revenue | $1.8Blower | $38.4Bhigher |
| Earnings | $1.1Blower | $2.4Bhigher |
| Employees | — | 65,805 |
| Total assets | $8.2Blower | $86.5Bhigher |
| Valuation | ||
| P/E | 30.2lower | 65.1higher |
| P/S | 26.2higher | 1.2lower |
| P/B | — | — |
| Dividend yield | — | — |
| Profitability | ||
| Operating margin | 74.3%higher | 15.4%lower |
| Balance sheet | ||
| Net assets | $7.6Blower | $33.5Bhigher |
| Total liabilities | $606.1Mlower | $52.2Bhigher |
| Total debt | — | — |
| Cash on hand | $670.9Mlower | $7.4Bhigher |
| Price change | ||
| Today | +2.99%higher | -0.38%lower |
| 1 year | +23.0%higher | -14.1%lower |
Market value, P/E, P/B, dividend yield and price changes are from live quotes (Yahoo Finance; prices may be delayed 15 minutes or more). Revenue, earnings, operating margin and the balance-sheet figures are from each company's latest annual report filed with the SEC (collected 2026-11-12); a company that reports in another currency is converted to US dollars at the exchange rate of that day. P/S sets today's market value against the latest fiscal year's revenue. “Higher” and “lower” compare the two numbers only; a higher P/E or more debt is not better. Dividend yield and P/B are shown only for companies based in the US. A dash means no figure is on file.
Which superinvestors hold them
From each tracked investor's latest 13F filing. A 13F lists long positions in US-listed shares at a quarter end, filed up to 45 days later.
Both (0)
None of the tracked investors.
Franco-Nevada only (6)
- Murray Stahl2.3%
- Matthew McLennan2.0%
- Tom Gayner1.5%
- Jim Simons (1938–2024)0.6%
- Steve Cohen0.2%
- Temasek<0.1%
Vale only (5)
- Christopher Davis0.2%
- Baillie Gifford team0.2%
- Ray Dalio (founder)0.2%
- Ken Fisher0.1%
- Richard Pzena<0.1%
Percentages are each holding's share of that investor's reported portfolio. Who owns FNV · Who owns VALE
More on Franco-Nevada
Further comparisons
Franco-Nevada against its closest peers
Vale against its closest peers
Learn
Questions and answers
Which is bigger, Franco-Nevada or Vale?
By market value, Franco-Nevada is the larger: $47.7B against $44.3B for Vale. By revenue in its latest fiscal year, Vale is the larger: $38.4B against $1.8B for Franco-Nevada.
Which has the higher P/E ratio?
Vale: 65.1, against 30.2 for Franco-Nevada. A higher P/E means the market pays more for each dollar of the last twelve months' earnings; on its own it does not say which is the better value.
Which has the higher operating margin?
Franco-Nevada: 74.3%, against 15.4% for Vale. Operating margin is operating income as a share of revenue in the latest fiscal year.
Which superinvestors own both Franco-Nevada and Vale?
None of the tracked superinvestors holds both in their latest 13F filing. 6 hold Franco-Nevada and 5 hold Vale.
Cite this page
Funkfolio, “Franco-Nevada vs Vale”, data as of 17 November 2026. https://funkfolio.com/compare/fnv-vs-vale
Underlying data: Yahoo Finance quotes; SEC annual reports collected 2026-11-12; 13F filings.