Etsy vs CarMax

Etsy (ETSY), consumer discretionary, and CarMax (KMX), consumer discretionary, side by side on market value, valuation, margins, balance sheet and price change. Higher and lower are marked; neither is called better.

Etsy and CarMax are valued at about the same: $7.1B and $7.1B. Etsy trades at 22.6 times earnings and CarMax at 24.5. Over the past year Etsy's share price has moved +56.0% and CarMax's +54.5%.

Key facts

Etsy market value
$7.1B
CarMax market value
$7.1B
Etsy P/E
22.6
CarMax P/E
24.5
Etsy revenue
$2.9BFY to 2025-12-31
CarMax revenue
$25.9BFY to 2026-02-28
Superinvestors holding both
0

Market values as of .

Etsy vs CarMax: every measure side by side
Measure Etsy CarMax
SectorConsumer DiscretionaryConsumer Discretionary
Country United States United States
Fiscal year ends2025-12-312026-02-28
Size
Market cap$7.1Blower$7.1Bhigher
Revenue$2.9Blower$25.9Bhigher
Earnings$163Mlower$247.3Mhigher
Employees2,375lower28,000higher
Total assets$2.8Blower$26.4Bhigher
Valuation
P/E22.6lower24.5higher
P/S2.5higher0.3lower
P/B—1.1
Dividend yield0.00%0.00%
Profitability
Operating margin9.23%—
Balance sheet
Net assets-$1.1Blower$5.9Bhigher
Total liabilities$3.9Blower$20.5Bhigher
Total debt$3Blower$18.1Bhigher
Cash on hand$1.4Bhigher$122.8Mlower
Price change
Today-2.80%lower-2.75%higher
1 year+56.0%higher+54.5%lower

Market value, P/E, P/B, dividend yield and price changes are from live quotes (Yahoo Finance; prices may be delayed 15 minutes or more). Revenue, earnings, operating margin and the balance-sheet figures are from each company's latest annual report filed with the SEC (collected 2026-11-12); a company that reports in another currency is converted to US dollars at the exchange rate of that day. P/S sets today's market value against the latest fiscal year's revenue. “Higher” and “lower” compare the two numbers only; a higher P/E or more debt is not better. Dividend yield and P/B are shown only for companies based in the US. A dash means no figure is on file.

Loading the one-year price chart…

Which superinvestors hold them

From each tracked investor's latest 13F filing. A 13F lists long positions in US-listed shares at a quarter end, filed up to 45 days later.

Percentages are each holding's share of that investor's reported portfolio. Who owns ETSY · Who owns KMX

Further comparisons

Learn

Questions and answers

Which is bigger, Etsy or CarMax?

By market value, CarMax is the larger: $7.1B against $7.1B for Etsy. By revenue in its latest fiscal year, CarMax is the larger: $25.9B against $2.9B for Etsy.

Which has the higher P/E ratio?

CarMax: 24.5, against 22.6 for Etsy. A higher P/E means the market pays more for each dollar of the last twelve months' earnings; on its own it does not say which is the better value.

Which has the higher dividend yield?

Neither: both stand at 0.00%. Dividend yield is the last twelve months' dividends as a share of today's share price.

Which has more debt?

CarMax: $18.1B, against $3B for Etsy. Total debt is borrowings at the end of the latest fiscal year, as each company reported it; it is not set against cash here.

Which superinvestors own both Etsy and CarMax?

None of the tracked superinvestors holds both in their latest 13F filing. 5 hold Etsy and 8 hold CarMax.

Cite this page

Funkfolio, “Etsy vs CarMax”, data as of 18 November 2026. https://funkfolio.com/compare/etsy-vs-kmx

Underlying data: Yahoo Finance quotes; SEC annual reports collected 2026-11-12; 13F filings.