Etsy vs CarMax
Etsy (ETSY), consumer discretionary, and CarMax (KMX), consumer discretionary, side by side on market value, valuation, margins, balance sheet and price change. Higher and lower are marked; neither is called better.
Etsy and CarMax are valued at about the same: $7.1B and $7.1B. Etsy trades at 22.6 times earnings and CarMax at 24.5. Over the past year Etsy's share price has moved +56.0% and CarMax's +54.5%.
Key facts
- Etsy market value
- $7.1B
- CarMax market value
- $7.1B
- Etsy P/E
- 22.6
- CarMax P/E
- 24.5
- Etsy revenue
- $2.9BFY to 2025-12-31
- CarMax revenue
- $25.9BFY to 2026-02-28
- Superinvestors holding both
- 0
Market values as of .
| Measure | Etsy | CarMax |
|---|---|---|
| Sector | Consumer Discretionary | Consumer Discretionary |
| Country | ||
| Fiscal year ends | 2025-12-31 | 2026-02-28 |
| Size | ||
| Market cap | $7.1Blower | $7.1Bhigher |
| Revenue | $2.9Blower | $25.9Bhigher |
| Earnings | $163Mlower | $247.3Mhigher |
| Employees | 2,375lower | 28,000higher |
| Total assets | $2.8Blower | $26.4Bhigher |
| Valuation | ||
| P/E | 22.6lower | 24.5higher |
| P/S | 2.5higher | 0.3lower |
| P/B | — | 1.1 |
| Dividend yield | 0.00% | 0.00% |
| Profitability | ||
| Operating margin | 9.23% | — |
| Balance sheet | ||
| Net assets | -$1.1Blower | $5.9Bhigher |
| Total liabilities | $3.9Blower | $20.5Bhigher |
| Total debt | $3Blower | $18.1Bhigher |
| Cash on hand | $1.4Bhigher | $122.8Mlower |
| Price change | ||
| Today | -2.80%lower | -2.75%higher |
| 1 year | +56.0%higher | +54.5%lower |
Market value, P/E, P/B, dividend yield and price changes are from live quotes (Yahoo Finance; prices may be delayed 15 minutes or more). Revenue, earnings, operating margin and the balance-sheet figures are from each company's latest annual report filed with the SEC (collected 2026-11-12); a company that reports in another currency is converted to US dollars at the exchange rate of that day. P/S sets today's market value against the latest fiscal year's revenue. “Higher” and “lower” compare the two numbers only; a higher P/E or more debt is not better. Dividend yield and P/B are shown only for companies based in the US. A dash means no figure is on file.
Which superinvestors hold them
From each tracked investor's latest 13F filing. A 13F lists long positions in US-listed shares at a quarter end, filed up to 45 days later.
Both (0)
None of the tracked investors.
Etsy only (5)
- Paul Singer2.6%
- Jim Simons (1938–2024)0.6%
- George Soros0.5%
- Brandon Haley0.3%
- Steve Cohen0.2%
CarMax only (8)
- Jeff Smith3.8%
- David Greenspan3.3%
- Karthik Sarma3.2%
- Steven Romick2.0%
- John Overdeck and David Siegel (founders)0.2%
- John Rogers0.2%
- Primecap team0.1%
- Tom Gayner0.1%
Percentages are each holding's share of that investor's reported portfolio. Who owns ETSY · Who owns KMX
More on Etsy
Further comparisons
Etsy against its closest peers
CarMax against its closest peers
Learn
Questions and answers
Which is bigger, Etsy or CarMax?
By market value, CarMax is the larger: $7.1B against $7.1B for Etsy. By revenue in its latest fiscal year, CarMax is the larger: $25.9B against $2.9B for Etsy.
Which has the higher P/E ratio?
CarMax: 24.5, against 22.6 for Etsy. A higher P/E means the market pays more for each dollar of the last twelve months' earnings; on its own it does not say which is the better value.
Which has the higher dividend yield?
Neither: both stand at 0.00%. Dividend yield is the last twelve months' dividends as a share of today's share price.
Which has more debt?
CarMax: $18.1B, against $3B for Etsy. Total debt is borrowings at the end of the latest fiscal year, as each company reported it; it is not set against cash here.
Which superinvestors own both Etsy and CarMax?
None of the tracked superinvestors holds both in their latest 13F filing. 5 hold Etsy and 8 hold CarMax.
Cite this page
Funkfolio, “Etsy vs CarMax”, data as of 18 November 2026. https://funkfolio.com/compare/etsy-vs-kmx
Underlying data: Yahoo Finance quotes; SEC annual reports collected 2026-11-12; 13F filings.